Mr. Pitchfork is a 1930s cartoon devil in a tailcoat, and he has a deal for everyone. You can fly, but ____. You get a four-day work week, but ____. Each player gets a different deal on their phone and writes the catch. Then the room votes on every contract, Deal or No deal, without knowing who wrote it.
The scoring turns the usual party game around. A catch that everyone loves scores almost nothing, and so does one that everyone refuses. The author scores most when the vote splits the room down the middle, with a bonus for an exact tie. Voters score too, for siding with the majority, so everyone has a reason to read the room. After three rounds of contracts (the last one counts double) comes the Final Contract: one would-you-rather for the whole group, where you pick a side and bet on what most people chose.
It runs on one shared screen, a TV or a screen share on a call, with every player on their own phone. Three to ten people can play, and a match takes about fifteen minutes from the first deal to the winner signing on the dotted line. The host or the first player to join can tear up any contract that goes too far, and a family-friendly setting keeps the stock deals clean. Groups can also bring their own deals and dilemmas.
How to play
Step 1
Put the stage on a big screen
Open the game on the screen everyone can see and start a room. Players scan the QR code or type the four-letter code on their phone, pick a name, and they're in. The first phone to join can start the match.
Step 2
Write the catch
Every player gets a different deal with a blank at the end. Write a catch that makes the deal tempting and awful at the same time. Stuck? Ask for the Devil's hint.
Step 3
Deal or No deal
The contracts come up one by one on the big screen, author hidden. Everyone else votes on their phone. You never vote on your own catch, you just watch the room.
Step 4
Split the room
The verdict drops the votes into two piles and names the author. The closer the split is to half and half, the more the author scores. Voters on the majority side get a smaller reward. The last round counts double.
Step 5
Sign the Final Contract
One last would-you-rather for the whole group. Pick your side, then predict which side most people picked. The best total signs the contract, and Mr. Pitchfork hands out awards for the best deal makers and the easiest marks.
How your group joins
Step 1
Open the game
The game opens a room for you and shows an invite link in its lobby.
Step 2
Send the link
Copy the invite link from the lobby and paste it in your group chat, Slack, Teams or the meeting chat.
Step 3
Everyone joins
Players open the link, type a name and they are in. No account and no download. Only you need an account.
Take Devilish Dilemma with you
The story, the facts and the artwork in a single PDF, ready for your deck or event proposal.






























